Close this search box.

Home of the best experts

Investments & markets, News, Regulation, enforcement & litigation
By Gontran de Quillacq
On May 11, 2021

The Libor manipulation whistleblower takes the entire CFTC pot

The risk manager who blew the whistle on Deutsche's Libor manipulation is entitled to a $100m award. That's a problem. It would empty the coffer for the entire program, and block other actions.

Whistleblower takes the entire CFTC gold potThe CFTC has a little hick-up in its whistleblower program. The Libor reward is so big, that it will deplete the entire fund.

Why paying the award is a problem

  • Since Dodd Frank in 2010, a whistleblower is entitled to 10-30% of the fines, disgorgements and proceeds collected by the agency. The percentage depends on the pertinence of the information and the culpability of the witness.
  • At the CFTC, the awards are paid from a dedicated fund. The treasure chest is filled by the collected penalties by the agency. By law, this fund has a limit of $100m.
  • Most awards are less than $1 m, sometimes a few $ millions. The Libor manipulation case was so big ($800 m collection for the CFTC, and $2.5 bn overall), that the $100m award would deplete the fund entirely.
  • If the award is paid out, the fund will not be replenished soon enough to pay any other whistleblower, and some actions are delayed or forfeited because of this.
  • Most seniors at the agency support paying the award, but not everybody support this – in the agency or above.
  • A bill to expand the fund has been languishing in congress. Senator Dick Grassley (R-IA), the ranking Republican on the Judiciary Committee, is supporting an extension of the fund to $150m, as well as an additional temporary funding process. The Agriculture Committee, which supervises the CFTC, has not yet taken up the matter.

The Deutsche case:

  • Deutsche Bank The whistleblower was a mid-level risk manager, who disclosed to the regulator the bets run by the firm’s traders to manipulate the Libor fixings. His career didn’t progress much afterwards.
  • Two traders were eventually convicted in 2018 on charges of manipulating Libor.
  • Deutsche Bank paid $800m to the CFTC, $775m to the DOJ and $900m to the SEC and another authority.
  • The CFTC initially denied the whistleblower any award, saying that they started the investigation from two WSJ articles and documents sent by Deutsche Bank.


Whistleblowers usually pay a high price for coming out. The cases often go nowhere. So it is important that they be rewarded when the wrongdoings are caught and punished, or they will not come forward.

The various whistleblowing programs are remarkably efficient tools to fight corruption and wrongdoing, at both corporations and government. There is political and lobby resistance, but also a strong social incentive to support those programs.


Credit to Alexandra Berzon at the WSJ.

Other article:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We would like to express our heartfelt thanks to you, our clients, for your continued and growing business with us. We're also excited to share some...
Investments & markets
The CFTC just fined Goldman for failure to properly disclose prices fairly to clients. And it's all about a technical issue related to the timing of...
Investments & markets
Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) defaulted on Friday. At $212 bn of assets, it is the largest failure since 2008, and probably one of the fastest -...
The financial industry is a legal and compliance minefield for its million+ members. Through the Financial Professionals Coalition, Stephen Kohn, Bill Singer, and a talented group...
Investments & markets
Xi Jinping's new leadership team will maintain the current direction. And China's GDP will slow; the Chinese economy is unlikely to reach that of the US...
Regulation, enforcement & litigation
Johnson & Johnson has spent billions on cases about one of its most popular products - talcum powder. As its executives try a brazen new legal...